Thursday, November 29, 2007

New feature: OpenID commenting

Blogger in Draft now lets you enable OpenID-based commenting, in your blogs' Settings | Comments tab:


(OpenID comments work in both the Anyone and Registered Users modes)

This means that users of OpenID-enabled services — such as LiveJournal and WordPress — can comment on your blog using their accounts from those sites, rather than with Blogger/Google accounts:

For example, if you see an OpenID comment with the URL http://brad.livejournal.com/, you'll know that it was Brad who wrote that comment, and not an impostor.

This feature is in Draft because we'd like to hear feedback about the implementation, and to test it further before moving it to Blogger's main site. We're also working on functionality to let Blogger's URLs (both Blog*Spot and custom domains) be used for commenting elsewhere on the web.

Let us know how this is working for you in the comments below.

Update, 12/3: We recommend Sam Ruby's OpenID for non-SuperUsers, which explains how to set up OpenID delegation. Delegation is a way for you to use your own URL for OpenID, but still sign in with AOL, LiveJournal, etc.

378 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   1 – 200 of 378   Newer›   Newest»
daveman692 said...

Awesome work!

herestomwiththeweather said...

Works great!

brianellin said...

beautiful!

bradfitz.com said...

Hell yeah! :)

micropat said...

test

.fosk. said...

Amazing :)

DarkUFO said...

Testing OpenID

ciphergoth said...

Marvellous - and hurrah for OpenID!

Andrew Chilton said...

Excellent news. Well done everyone at the Google Team making such good things happen.

hughe said...

oo nice

www said...

I just installed OpenID on my site, so this is a double-test. :)

Oh, hey, a blank user-agent. Any chance you could put something in there? :)

cowsandmilk said...

I love openid

www said...

What? "www" is a totally awesome screen name! :P

openid said...

I'm using a personal OpenID! Works!

dan-rastor said...

Спасибо

ltd said...

wild!

sethop said...

Cool, I've been waiting for this!

But do you think you still need the word verification for OpenID comments? In theory that bit belongs on the user login side of things?

Hey, I initially tried using my usual OpenID which is sethop.com and it failed - possibly because I'm using a delegated openid provider?

n8k99 said...

i'd like to see this on my blogger hosted blog but without the captcha

emeraldfirst said...

jjhhh

iake said...

ยอดเยี่ยม กระเทียมเจียว

Excellent :D

thejeshgn said...

cool feature

Ücretsiz Bilgisayar Dergisi said...

Ücretsiz Bilgisayar Dergisi pdfdergi nin testi. Wordpress hesabıma erişemediğim için blogger hesabım üzerinden yapıyorum OPENID testini. Pek alakası yok ama...

iake said...

Works great!

Khürt Williams said...

I would like see OpenID supported more among the blogging services. I have blogs are Wordpress.com and Blogger. It sucks when I find a Blogger hosted blog I want to comment on but first I have to login into Blogger. My comment then links back to my Blogger account which is not my main blog.

ppalavilli said...

wonderful

lunamoth said...

hi

Andrew said...

Glad to see this... I'm sure the folks at WordPress.com are watching...

Ed said...

It's working

maydanikas said...

Ну-ка, посмотрим...

eric said...

Perfect.

Pure_BY said...

Really very nice! Thanks!
Try to implement Blogger in as much services, as possible!
Thanks again :)

linickx said...

Testing OpenID :)

jamesdkirk said...

Even though there are challenges with the security concepts behind openID, they'll get dealt with eventually. Heck, I can't even tell you how many "security updates" get applied automatically to my Windows install...

Great to see a major platform pushing openID forward. Great job!

Lisa said...

Technorati monster keeps borking on me, but I love the idea. When would this be available to us?

misha said...

yes! waiting for google account as identity url :)

ian said...

nice work!

Anang said...

test

DeWitt Clinton said...

Really, how can we *not* love it? (Posted using Verisign as the IDP and one of my own domains as the OpenID URL.)

Anang said...

test

sumitcompaq said...

works!!!

Kevin said...

This looks cool.... I don't think that other blogging service is currently providing such kind of service.

harryh said...

word

sxalexander said...

This is great! Its good to see some sweet OpenID action!

palam said...

Great

norman said...

awesome!

jernst said...

Congratulations!

parand.com said...

Testing.

David Blume said...

Commenting with "Any OpenID".

Am very hopeful, and glad you did this!

Boy said...

how to put/activate this excellent feature in my blog?

chicagokarl said...

test

SexySEO said...

Congrats! This is really great work!

lebedew.ru said...

Test in progress..
It's works!!
Great!

freetree said...

Nice.

Josh said...
This post has been removed by the author.
j3h said...

Fails silently if JavaScript is not enabled.

Darnell Clayton said...

Cheers to the Blogger team for this one!

At this rate, I am never leaving blogger for any alternative!

Unless I decide to host my own blog on my server of course...but then again, if Google wants to pay for it on my domain, why leave?

mart said...

I'm going to join the barrage of people posting just to test it. :)

pierre said...

really cool !
it's working for orange.fr user too (openid.orange.fr)
Si vous etes clients Orange vous pouvez vous creer un compte openid sur http://openid.orange.fr

johnpanzer.com said...

It's great to see all of these comments (and all of the different OpenIDs....). I'll be at the Internet Identity Workshop next week to chat about this and other issues.

jeremykrall said...

Cool!

factoryjoe said...

This is awesome awesome AWESOME! I'm so glad you guys are now support this.

gokhans said...

Thanks..
Test ediyorum bakalım..

scottag said...

Coolness.

afroginthevalley said...

Intéressant, merci!

terrellrussell said...

excellent.

well done. another feather for open standards.

David Hogue said...

Nice!

(just testing)

Jegres Hydes (Sirozha) said...

very nice, guys

Patton said...

it works!

Citizen Dave said...

Excellent feature, well done.

cgull said...

I don't see this feature in my blog. But is an awesome feature. Please also add Friends list.

helvick said...

Works for me!

Boris said...

Could not resist -- wonderful!

Matt said...

Very cool! One request: Capitalize the P in WordPress.

(We should do something like this.)

josephholsten said...

Now we simply need a google OP, (blogger? orkut? gooid.com?) so all google accounts work on other OpenID RPs

bobwyman said...

This is excellent!

Peter said...

neato !!

Peter said...

Neato0...

hmmmm..now which one of my open Id's should I use :)-

john said...

this is neat !

but we NEED openID@gmail.com to be an accepted OpenID platform

axodys said...

This is pretty sweet.

uggedal said...

Finally!

rodbegbie said...

Rawk on. Glad you've done this.

John Stansbury said...

I tried using TypeKey but that doesn't seem to work. Is there something in there I'm missing?

karit said...

testing open id

goto said...

just testing OpenID,

gaurav.kanoongo said...

Wow, It's great. I wish Google enable OpenID support across all of it's services.

dwaite said...

Awesome! (ok, really just a reason to test OpenID)

david said...

Is there a way to 'log in' using OpenID, so I don't need to choose everytime?

duck1123 said...

Will blogger validate the OpenID if anonymous comments are on and the commenter enters a URL that is OpenID-enabled?

Also, does it support delegated identities? I can't seem to comment with my OpenID, but I can with the one it delegates to.

Esaj said...

Cool tapes!

atomic1fire said...

this is a pretty awesome job
Im surprised you guys rolled this out now after all this time but I guess its now or never :)

Samuel said...

test

unloud said...

Thank you!

Think Smarter said...

looks good to me

damm said...

... test...

anonymous said...

Testing

Mike Goad said...

So what happened to the ability to sign in using your name and URL on Blogger? (Not Blogger-in-Draft, but the currently on line, out-in-the-world Blogger) I comment on a lot of blogs and I'm getting to the point where I cringe every time I want to comment on a blog that's on blogger.

emer77 said...

Please, other google sites too!

dogboi said...

Sweet. This is such a good idea. I love OpenID

Brinstar said...

Test!

koji said...

OpenID 対応、すばらしいです。

Sushubh said...

test

pawitp said...

Ooh Ooh Ooh OpenID!

Nico said...

I tested with some of my openids:
1) direct openid is working (let's say myname.myopenid.com)

2) delegation is not working (let's say www.mydomain.net/myname delegated to myname.myopenid.com server)

3) redirect is not working (myname.mydomain.net redirection to www.mydomain.net/myname delegated to myname.myopenid.com server)

anyone?

witman said...

できるかな

zheng said...

Look forward to more on the function of openid

thatgingerguy.com said...

Wowzers!

Sunny said...

Great move towards a healthy web and happy users :)

xtof said...

merci blogger. cool news pour openidfrance :-)

duck1123 said...

test

anantshri said...

It a long awaited feature, Now i see huge potential of openid.


and a ton's of thanks to google crew for the work.

Kevin said...

nice. i want this on my own blog right now.

ryan said...

whee, it's out!

Vaclav Synacek said...

Very good news for OpenID!

ruiabreuferreira said...

Been waiting for this for ages, now! OpenID is great.

Katoh said...

Now mabye OpenID will see a wider userbase, it just needs to be used in more Google Apps. (You guys need to support the 2.0 spec)

Ken said...

Wow. This is a great idea!

yktdan said...

See if this works with my openid

Walt said...

try again with another openid

D. Moonfire said...

I really think that OpenID is a great way to go. I don't have a blogger blog myself, but the only reason I have an account is simply to post, so having OpenID would let me use my real id and simplify the number of places I need to remember a logon. :)

Oh, and maybe someplace to have emails sent to. If that is possible.

pat said...

cool!

maseko said...

Ngetest aja

maseko said...

Testing with my blog URL

leafmold said...

Awesome!

Pascal Van Hecke said...

Testing!

MrStone said...

If really think OpenID is Great!!

dataphage said...

Please google, become an openID provider. Please...

Ravi said...

good!

kim said...

Absolutely cool. Congratulations

wesdley said...

testando openid

Jeber said...

Universal electronic ID takes another step toward reality.

kim said...

Like nico, I was unable to get delegation to work (e.g. the link tags in my web page (identityblog) pointing to my openid provider.

Is the problem at your end or with myopenid.com?

kim said...

Congratulations to the Blogger team! Now I'll start leaving comments on Blogger blogs!

iake said...

test

gwachob said...

Is this openid 1.1 or 2.0?

www said...

Trying to debug my referal problem

www said...

If someone wants to know how to get redirection, my page now works.

www said...

If people use a url like I do, the www part isn't very informative. I would recommend you show more of the url.

zizukabi said...

I would like to suggest you that anyone have not google account or openid can comment with his own url but now that method can't seen in comment block. Only listed service account can comment at this time.

Boris said...

Since "http://openid.aol.com/'name'@mac.com are" the openids for every ".mac" user: It would be nice to have a ".mac" scheme in the sign in drop down box.

nimitzx said...

Nice

Larry said...

OpenID 2.0 support seems to be broken. XRIs don't work either as normal or with xri:// prefix.

spouseele said...

I like very much the integration of OpenID and Windows CardSpace!

spouseele said...

test

spouseele said...

test 2

tom said...

testing

Ewout said...

Test no webdevcamp 2007

mykdavies said...

just a test

carlabodoni said...

Prueba

Gurpreet said...
This post has been removed by the author.
Intruso said...

Hi, testeando ID

bsnyder said...

OpenID is the way! I'm glad to see this initiative finally taking off. Down with that proprietary id crapola!

Kiliman said...

test

anthonybailey said...

Yet another test.

Whilst I'm here... I happen to host my blog on LiveJournal, so using them as an OpenID provider is easy, but I guess I really should be using or forwarding to a domain under my own control, shouldn't I? So that my OpenID can persist across service provider changes, I mean.

petenixey said...

Great to see this.

Joel said...

openID thing is great! I've enabled it :)

MS said...

I am extremely unhappy about the dropping of the URL field, which gave bloggers the option of directing anyone interested to a specific blog. There are a number of Blogger users at BlogCatalog who are considering leaving Blogger for this reason.

If you are going to force someone to have an ID, then open ID is good, but I think no one should be forced to make their users log in, and I think that those who don't log in should be able to put a URL in a URL field marked "(optional)".

The optional addition, by the way, matters. I've had users email me and say they would comment, but they didn't have a blog. They thought that URL was mandatory.

Those of you who are excited should consider the hurdle you are placing before potential commenters. I refuse to comment on a blog for which I have to log in, not on principle, but because rarely is the content so compelling that I feel I must jump through hoops.

Long story short, any additional options like this one and the associated decision to remove the URL field from comments should be *options* and nothing else.

On a related note, I also don't use word verification. I appreciate that the option is there, but I have not needed it and so am quite happy to not have to place this hurdle in front of potential commenters. This is an example of Blogger doing something right, allowing me to make choices that are sensible for each of my blogs. Let's have more of what is right and less of the stuff that makes me want to cut and run.

Rose said...

Just testing.

RockStories said...

I heard there was a very positive response to this and was surprised, but now that I look at the post I can see why...it's because the "addition" of the openID option has been entirely separated from the removal of the ability for non-Blogger bloggers to leave URLs when they comment...and the removal of the ability for even Blogger bloggers to leave the direct URL to their blogs.

So, while this is certainly a better option than allowing only Blogger/Google registered visitors to post comments, it fails to address the most serious problems created by the removal of the URL field from the comment form: the inability of a blogger (whether registered with Blogger/Google or not) to leave a link back to his relevant blog, and the inability of Blogspot bloggers to identify traffic sources based on comments they've made on other Blogspot blogs.

MS said...

Exactly, Rockstories. I was just going through the old posts for this blog, and I see *nothing* that announces the lost feature. That is not good. Selling a major change in policy as a new feature spells of doublespeak, and I don't like it.

For what it's worth, I have also considering having my history students start blogs next semester. I've been thinking about platform and also the potential value of a Wiki instead. Blogger is giving me new food for thought.

But maybe someone just forgot to post about the removal of the other feature? Is that possible? Please tell me that's so, and please ask for our feedback on the issue, instead of just requesting applause for the OpenID move.

Kathy Frederick said...

Count me in among the people who think this loss of the ability to enter your own URL in comments will have serious consequences. Namely, leaving Blogger for something better. Please resume the option to leave a URL. My (and others) futures with Blogger depend on it.

sepintx said...

testing open ID

curt said...

nice to see the support for openID!

snydez said...

test ahhhh..

Jeff said...

I'm with everyone else above about the loss of URL links in comments. Why would you drop that feature? Going backwards is not what I look for in a blog host.

EF said...

double cool

www said...

I added the necessary openID magic gloop to the header of my blog page (you can see what to do by searching for openid in the source of my homepage) and now when I use OpenID my link seems to be there as my name.

Don't know if this satisfies some of the complaints above, but I like it.

Of course I think a blogger should be able to set up her blog however they want to...

coolengineer said...

May God bless you.

Llusan said...

Felicitacion a los amigos de blogger.
Ojala pronto habiliten la opcion de utilizar formularios integrados a la pagina.

Gracias por todo, que Dios los bendiga!

shimaken7 said...

test from japan

liveid said...

does google plan to use openid for gmail?

lordsam said...

Super !

Tim said...

Long overdue. I look forward to updating this post with the good news.

Using a Typekey ID works fine, but is there any chance of making signing in with a Technorati profile easier?

Mtzvd said...

Doesn't work with my Livejournal account

matgb said...

@ Kathy, and others—the idea of OpenID is that it is your Blog url, for the most part. I'm commenting here using my LJ OpenID, but I could just as easily use one of my politics or gaming blogs, all of which are OpenIDs for me, some of them already powered by Blogger. It's a simple process for an admin of a site to make the site itself and OpenID for one specific person, and that's a Good Thing.

This means that you can no longer have someone pretend to be you in comments, something that has been a specific problem in the past in some blogging communities.

@ Brad, Karl, Dave et al. Well done, kudos, and roll on the full implementation, especially built in support for blog admins to use their blogspot URLs (because even though it's easy to set up, most don't know how to).

Alex said...

great news

mtzvd said...

though, it worked from my other Livejournal account.

That's wierd

mtzvd.livejournal.com - working
matizovod.livejournal.com - not working

MS said...

@matgb, who writes, "the idea of OpenID is that it is your Blog url, for the most part"

This statement presupposes that a person has only one blog and only blogs on one subject. I have several blogs, each with a different focus. I want to be able to use a different URL, depending on whose blog i am commenting on. If its a Mac blog, i'll link my Mac blog. If it's about military history, I'll link my blog that relates to that, and so on.

Have a look at the various blog directories, especially MyBlogLog and BlogCatalog. Yo will see many, perhaps most bloggers there with multiple blogs, and they have multiple blogs for a reason. Each one deals with a different subject.

@ some of the recent commenters who merely write that this is cool: Did you read the other comments here for additional information and viewpoints? Or are you just applauding the initial post, which doesn't even announce the loss of the URL field?

MS said...

Regarding the actual implementation of OpenID, you should include a note in the field that explains that there are options. Yes, you have a drop-down menu, but you also have bloggers with years of conditioning who think it is either use the Blogger ID or choose the nickname field.

Alternatively, or in addition, you could add a field to the comments settings that allows the individual blog owner to include a message to commenters. Haloscan permits this, for example.

Guachapeli said...

Acabo de descubrir este blog de blogger y me parecen fantasticos estas nuevas posibilidades (OpenID commenting, encuestas, gadgets...).

Lo que me parece mal es que se tarden tanto en implementar definitivamente en blogger.

179 comments in five days, ouh!!!

También me ha extrañado no ver ningun otro comentario en español
Gracias

radix said...

Let's see if this works...

jodi said...

I'm not happy at all with what has been done to blogger's comment form. People who visit my blog like to be able to have their name link back to their own blog URL even if they're with another blogging system, and now suddenly that's not working for them.

I think this is shortsighted of Blogger, and like others, if this facet is not reinstated I will in likelihood look at moving my blog to a more user- and visitor-friendly site.

LaShon James-Major said...

Currently I'm not in favor but we'll see. I'm really considering switching blogs, this is a hassle.

805.444.2366 said...

I really don't like it. I have always liked checking the blog of the person that has commented on my site. This will stop that. I may be looking to find a new blog platform as well.

My Mobile Notary said...

How ridiculous is this! I want to see the blog site of the poster. I'm not interested in this new game. Looks like it's time to go searching for something new.

barisg said...

test

Rich said...

I'm not sure I understand the logic of precluding anonymous posters OR precluding OpenID links; it seems the division is steeper than it needed to be.

The roll out seems very passive in terms of communication too, eg. didn't even register on the blogger buzz blog.

Best,
Rich

Kathy Frederick said...

Come on Google! Throw us a bone. I don't feel like moving to a new platform. But you leave us no choice.

SUEB0B said...

How is it that everyone likes this? My commenters hate it. They would like to be able to use any URL in the field. It really seems kind of suckworthy.

phydeaux3 said...

Testing using my blogspot url as an OpenID delegate.

It works. I zink.

I like the change. I agree with it.
But I would say it could have been communicated way better. To make the change (right before the weekend) and not really explain the why of removing the anonymous links breeds unnecessary excitement. It finally has a page on the Known Issues blog, but you know bloggers. No one reads that. :-)
At least an announcement on The Buzz should have gone up (since it goes to the dashboard), knowing how people would react to seeing something they were used to disappear. My two cents.

ndevtuna said...

keep work

peter_lemenkov said...

Works

sciencebase said...

Much better than one's name pointing to a useless Blogspot profile

Mr. magicball said...

This is a very bad feature, because now only professionals can comment blogpost. No normal visitors would do that that way. Of course it is better for Google to get any information around about social contacts between bloggers. But this brings money to Google and takes money away from blogowners. Very bad.

Jos said...

I think this may be a good feature..

I do have some problems, however.

First, with the fact that the original 'other' option, where commentors could leave their name with a link to their url, was brutally removed from the comment section, without any communication about that, and without mentioning the new feature. This has led to a huge frustration among many users, who were not aware that a new feature was in draft!

Second, I am wondering what impact the new identiciation pull down may have on the 'do follow' movement?

And third, I believe there should be a choice for blog owners to leave the old 'other' option available or not.

Jeff said...

This is excellent.

Alwen said...

Actually, the only comment I've gotten on it is:

"Am I missing something in your comment area, it doesn't allow me to put in the URL for my blog anymore."

gautami tripathy said...

I too used to leave my direct link on blogger with the "other" option. Noethat feature is unavailable for blogspot users.

I want a choice. There seems to be none for now.

acheung said...

Great move. That's real fresh air.

En sommerfugl said...

While I do think that supporting OpenID is a great addition, I'm quite dismayed with the very unfriendly removal of the ability for "other" commenters to leave their URL. This was really useful. I'd suggest to make this an optional feature, enabling bloggers to be strict if the need is felt. As a lot of different "small" blogging platforms exist, OpenID can not be a replacement.

Штирлиц said...

This is cool!

«Oldest ‹Older   1 – 200 of 378   Newer› Newest»